If you’ve ever hired an independent contractor, whether that’s a VA, designer, copywriter, or business strategist, you might’ve had this thought at some point:
What’s stopping them from taking what they learned working with me and using it for someone else… or worse, becoming my competition?
This thought comes up a LOT for business owners and it’s honestly one of the things that actually keeps people from working with independent contractors in the first place.
It’s like you want to outsource, but you don’t want to risk them stealing your business concepts or ideas. And I’ll be the first to say that’s totallyyyy valid.
But I also want you to know that there are contract protections you can put in place to reduce the risk, set clear boundaries, and give your business a stronger path to respond if a contractor misuses your information, solicits your clients, or crosses a line.
A lot of business owners think that a non-compete clause in their contracts does the trick and while on the surface it sounds like the perfect solution, when it comes to legal contracts, non-compete clauses aren’t always as simple (or as enforceable) as they seem.
That’s why in this blog post, we’re breaking down what a non-compete clause actually is, when it makes sense to use one (and when it doesn’t), what it can realistically do, and what other contract protections may be even more effective for your business!
Short answer: Most online business owners do not need a broad non-compete clause for independent contractors. In many situations, a confidentiality clause, non-solicitation clause, intellectual property clause, and clear scope of work will protect the business more effectively and with less enforceability risk. A non-compete may be worth considering only when the contractor has access to highly sensitive strategy, client relationships, or proprietary systems, and only if the restriction is narrow and allowed under applicable state law.
Quick legal note: non-compete law is changing quickly and varies a lot by state. The FTC’s broad federal non-compete rule is not currently in effect, but non-competes are still heavily regulated under state law, and some states ban or sharply limit them for employees and independent contractors. Before adding a non-compete clause to an independent contractor agreement, make sure the restriction is allowed in the state law that applies to your contractor relationship.
What Is a Non-Compete Clause for Independent Contractors?
Put simply, a non-compete clause is a contract term that tries to restrict someone from working with competitors, accepting certain types of work, or starting a competing business for a period of time after the relationship ends. Depending on the state, it may need to be limited by time, geography, type of work, compensation level, or legitimate business interest, and in some states it may not be allowed at all.
When used with independent contractors, this clause typically aims to prevent them from:
- Offering similar services to your competitors
- Working with your clients directly
- Starting a business that directly competes with yours
For an online business, a generic mileage-based restriction is often not the best fit. A more targeted restriction, if allowed by applicable law, would focus on the specific competitive activity, client relationship, confidential information, or project context that creates the risk.
Sounds pretty simple and straightforward, right? Welllll, here’s where things get tricky…
Independent contractors are supposed to operate as separate businesses, so a broad non-compete can create two problems at once: it may be harder to enforce, and it may look inconsistent with the idea that the contractor is truly independent. That matters because worker classification continues to be an active legal issue, and the Department of Labor has proposed revising its analysis for distinguishing employees from independent contractors under federal wage and hour law.
When Should You Use a Non-Compete Clause for Independent Contractors?
With that in mind, here’s some guidance on when a non-compete clause makes sense and when it’s probably not the best fit.
|
Situation |
Better Protection |
|
Contractor will see confidential business strategy |
Confidentiality clause |
|
Contractor will create content, designs, systems, or assets |
Intellectual property assignment clause |
|
Contractor will interact with your clients |
Client non-solicitation clause |
|
Contractor will access passwords, accounts, or internal systems |
Confidentiality, access controls, and return-of-materials clause |
|
Contractor may start a similar business someday |
Usually not a broad non-compete |
|
Contractor may directly poach your clients using your relationship |
Non-solicitation clause |
When A Non-Compete Clause Might Make Sense
There are certain situations where a non-compete clause may be appropriate, including scenarios like:
- You’re sharing highly sensitive business strategies or proprietary processes
- The contractor has deep access to your client relationships or internal systems
- The contractor plays a key role in your business operations
- You’re trying to prevent direct competition in a very specific, limited way
Even in these cases, the clause needs to be reasonable in scope, time, and geography, which means it shouldn’t be overly broad, it’s not indefinite, and it’s not restricting someone from working entirely in their field.
Before adding a non-compete clause, ask:
- What exact risk am I trying to prevent?
- Could a confidentiality, non-solicitation, or IP clause solve the issue instead?
- Is the contractor in a state that bans or limits non-competes?
- Is the restriction narrow in time, scope, and activity?
- Would this make the contractor look less independent?
- Would a strong contractor agreement protect the business without restricting the contractor’s whole career?
When A Non-Compete Clause Probably Isn’t The Right Fit
In many cases, however, non-compete clauses for independent contractors are either unnecessary or unenforceable.
Scenarios where that’s often the case include things like:
- You’re hiring for short-term or project-based work
- The contractor works with multiple clients (which is standard)
- The clause would prevent them from earning a living in their industry
- You’re trying to broadly block them from working with “any competitors”
This is especially important in online businesses where geography is unclear and competition is harder to define.
In these situations, a non-compete clause can do more harm than good, either by not holding up legally or by deterring high-quality contractors from working with you in the first place!
What a Non-Compete Clause for Independent Contractors Can Actually Do
Knowing all of this, it’s important to next look at what a non-compete clause for independent contractors can actually do because, most of the time, business owners have the wrong idea!
The biggest thing to realize is that a non-compete clause is not a catch-all protection and it doesn’t guarantee that someone won’t compete with you.
What it may be able to do, if allowed under applicable law, is create a narrow boundary around very specific competitive conduct.
It Can Deter Direct Competition (If Reasonable)
A well-drafted non-compete may discourage a contractor from directly targeting your clients or operating in a very specific competitive space if the terms are reasonable. But again, this is not absolute protection.
It Can Strengthen Your Position in a Dispute
If a contractor clearly violates a narrowly drafted and enforceable non-compete clause, it may give your business a stronger contract-based claim. However, enforcement often depends on state laws, the wording of the clause, and whether the restriction is considered fair.
It Cannot Completely Prevent Competition
This is the biggest misconception that business owners have when it comes to non-compete clauses!
You generally cannot stop an independent contractor from working in their industry, offering similar services to others, and growing their own business.
That’s simply the game of business.
Trying to implement a non-compete that would prevent an independent contractor from doing any of those things often ends up being a clause that’s too broad to legally enforce.
Better Contract Clauses to Use With Independent Contractors
So if a non-compete clause isn’t always the answer, what CAN you do to protect your business when working with independent contractors?
The answer is actually pretty simple: implement well-rounded key contracts that include the rightclauses throughout.
And no, I’m not going to leave you guessing on what key contracts and clauses can help you protect your business in a more practical, well-rounded way.
Here’s what I would recommend having as a business owner that wants to hire independent contractors:
Independent Contractor Agreement
First things first, this is your foundational contract when hiring independent contractors.
Truly, if you implement nothing else, let it be this! (But please, don’t skip the others).
Your independent contractor agreement should clearly outline:
✔️ Scope of work
✔️ Payment terms
✔️ Ownership of work
✔️ Expectations and responsibilities
This agreement sets the tone for the entire working relationship and reduces misunderstandings from the start.
Confidentiality Clause
Next up is a confidentiality clause and this can actually be even more effective than a non-compete clause!
A confidentiality clause prohibits contractors from sharing or misusing your business strategies, client information, pricing structures, and internal processes.
This protects the information that actually gives your business a competitive edge without restricting someone’s ability to work!
Non-Solicitation Clause
If your main concern is contractors taking your clients, a non-solicitation clause is often the better solution than a non-compete!
This clause prevents contractors from soliciting your clients, attempting to move clients away from your business, and directly profiting from relationships built through your business.
It’s typically more enforceable than a non-compete because it’s more targeted and less restrictive!
Intellectual Property Clause
Whether you’re working with independent contractors or not, I highly recommend that all business owners have an intellectual property clause. It’s the clause that helps make ownership clear so the work created for your business is properly assigned or licensed to you.
Without this, there can be confusion around ownership of designs, copy, content, systems, etc. Overall, this clause protects your assets longgg after the contract ends!
Scope of Work + Boundaries
While not a legal “protection” in the traditional sense, clearly defining the scope of work helps prevent overreach and confusion during the working relationship with an independent contractor.
This is often something that you will very clearly include in your independent contractor agreement, but can also be reiterated during onboarding and throughout the project if needed.
Ultimately, having a detailed scope of work and boundaries around things like communication, working hours, etc. creates a professional structure that reinforces your business operations!
What If Someone Asks You to Sign a Non-Compete as an Independent Contractor?
If you are the contractor being asked to sign a non-compete, read it carefully before agreeing. A broad non-compete can limit your ability to serve other clients, market your services, or grow your own business after the project ends.
Before signing, look for:
- A restriction that lasts too long
- A restriction that covers too many competitors or industries
- A restriction that applies nationwide or online without a clear reason
- A restriction that stops you from offering your normal services
- A restriction that applies even if you never receive confidential information or client access
If the clause feels too broad, ask whether the business would accept a narrower confidentiality, non-solicitation, or IP ownership clause instead.
FAQs About Non-Compete Clauses for Independent Contractors
Can you use a non-compete clause with an independent contractor?
Sometimes, but it depends on state law and how the clause is written. Some states ban or heavily limit non-competes for independent contractors, while others may allow narrow restrictions tied to legitimate business interests.
Is a non-solicitation clause better than a non-compete?
Often, yes. If your main concern is protecting client relationships, a narrow non-solicitation clause is usually more targeted than a broad non-compete.
Can I stop a contractor from working with competitors?
Usually, not broadly. A contractor is generally allowed to run their own business and serve other clients. If there is a specific risk, focus the contract on confidential information, client solicitation, IP ownership, and misuse of your business assets.
What should I use instead of a non-compete?
For many online businesses, the better contract stack is an independent contractor agreement with confidentiality, non-solicitation, IP ownership, payment, scope, access, and return-of-materials provisions.
The goal is not to restrict every move a contractor makes. Rather, the goal is to protect the parts of your business that actually need protection: your confidential information, client relationships, original content, systems, and paid work product. That starts with a strong Independent Contractor Agreement, not a generic non-compete pasted into the bottom of a contract.
Set Your Business Up with the Right Contractor Agreements
So, do you need a non-compete clause for independent contractors? The most simple (and sort of annoying, I know 🫣) answer I can give you is: it depends! But in many cases, it’s not going to be the strongest or most practical form of protection.
Non-compete clauses can be useful in very specific, limited situations, but they must be carefully written to be enforceable. And even then, they won’t completely prevent competition.
Instead of relying solely on a non-compete, the most effective approach is building a contract that protects your business from multiple angles!
If you’re working with independent contractors and want to make sure your contracts are set up the right way, having professionally drafted agreements makes all the difference.
Inside The Boutique Lawyer Contract Shop, you’ll find attorney-drafted contract templates for online business owners, including an Independent Contractor Agreement designed to clarify scope, payment, confidentiality, intellectual property ownership, and other key terms before the work begins.
Because the goal isn’t just to have a contract – it’s to have one that works for you. 👏🏼
ABOUT THE AUTHOR, AMBER GILORMO – ATTORNEY AND FOUNDER OF THE BOUTIQUE LAWYER
Amber Gilormo is the cool lawyer behind The Boutique Lawyer – a one-stop contract template shop for creative entrepreneurs, online business owners, coaches, and service providers.
From client agreements to digital product terms and everything in between, our lawyer-drafted templates help you put stronger legal foundations in place without getting buried in legal jargon.
Here’s how you can stay connected:
🖋️ Let’s be pen pals! Subscribe to my email list to receive all of my best biz tips and behind the scenes goodies to keep your business bringing in sales (legally of course).
📄 Binge the blog to get all of the legal information you need about running a business in a way that actually makes sense to your non-legal brain.
👋 Come hang with me on the ‘gram! I often do AMA’s on stories, so you can submit your specific questions when they come up.